按上见于刘嗣宗温疫论类编序。
〔唐氏(大烈)吴医汇讲〕十卷 存
自序曰。粤稽炎晖纪物。首垂本草之经。云瑞名官。肇启灵兰之笈。宗传历代。各立家言。派衍至今。尤工
搜录。篁南江氏有类案之编。东逸罗君有汇粹之选。惟渊源之有自。斯纪述之多人。矧吾吴文献之邦。乃良医荟萃之
域。韩门昆季。擅卢扁之称。葛氏乔梓。绍张刘之学。新甫启东二十子。前朝之着述已繁。生洲路玉诸公。圣代之
阐扬亦伙。印机草。识元仪临证之慎重。读书记。知在泾学业之深沉。凡此各自成书。出自诸家见地。康熙时。
有过君绎之者。裒集众贤治案。合镂为书。名曰吴中医案。此又片善悉录。一艺必庸。旁搜博采而成者也。夫广
罗成效。固以志乡先辈之典型。而各抒论言。亦以征诸君子之诣力。况乎精是业者。高才不少。明其理者。卓识
自多。匿采藏光。非乏枕中之秘。灵机妙绪。讵鲜囊底之珍。凡属蕴藏。可胜惋惜。仆谨仿吴中医案之旧帙。更
辑吴医汇讲之新编。奥义显词。统为求教。长篇短节。并曰无拘。苟步武之克追。期当仁之不让。乃荷固志。弗
蕲辉光。共表深思。互相赏新。或疏往训。既发覆而摘微。或出心裁。尤领新而标异。诠玉版之秘要。欣符丽泽
之占。索金匮之真言。胥协盍簪之庆。勿谓禁方三十。独推思邈得其奇。须知肘后四编。不惟抱朴穷其蕴。纵酿
花为蜜。未免书癖之讥。而集腋成裘。堪补艺林之阙。乾隆壬子仲秋。长洲唐大烈立三氏书于问心草堂。
〔武夷应道人秘传诸病药方〕一卷 存
〔赵氏(学敏)医林集腋〕十六卷 未见
〔养素园传信方〕六卷 未见
按上见于汇刻书目。
〔沈氏(丹彩)医谱〕未见
钱大昕序曰。沈子丹彩。吾邑世族。少时弃去毕业。独究心医方五行壬遁之术。皆有神解。又以为占筮之失。
止于不HT 。惟方药主于对病。病之名同也。而或感于外。或伤于内。或实而宜泻。或虚而宜补。疑似之间。毫厘
千里。学医费人。为祸尤烈。乃博涉古今方书。分类采辑。辨受病之源。而得制方之用。为医谱若干卷。既成。
将付之剞劂。而属予一言序之。予复于丹彩曰。子亦知相马之说乎。昔者伯乐言九方皋于秦穆公。公使行求焉。
三月而反。报曰。得之矣。其马牝而黄。公使人往取之。牡而骊。召伯乐而让之曰。子所使求马者。色物牡牝。
尚弗能知。又何马之能知也。伯乐喟然太息曰。技一至于此乎。皋之所观者。天机也。得其精而忘其粗。在其内
而忘其外。见其所见。而不见
其所不见。是乃所以千万臣而无数者也。汉马文渊少师事杨子阿。受相为骨法。及征交趾。得骆越铜鼓。铸为马
式。以为传闻不如亲见。视景不如察形。乃根据仪氏HT 。中帛氏口齿。谢氏唇 。丁氏身中。备此数家骨相以为法。
夫伯乐之于马。观其天机而已。色物牝牡。且不暇辨。而伏波乃斤于口齿唇 。支节分寸。一一取其相肖。此与
皮相者何异。然伯乐世不常有。而相马之法。不可不传。将欲使物尽其才。人藉其用。骅骝毋困于盐车。驽蹇勿
参乎上驷。舍伏波铜马之式。将奚观哉。古人本草石之寒温。量疾病之深浅。辨五苦六辛。致水火之齐。以通闭
解结。于是乎有十一家之经方。此犹伏波相马之有式也。而善医者又云。上医要在视脉。脉之妙处不可得传。虚
着方剂。无益于世。此伯乐所云。观其天机。不见其所不见者也。今子既精于察脉。洞见垣一方。而复集古今证
治之法。为谱以示后人。其有合于伏波之意乎。虽然。按寸不及尺。握手不足足。相对斯须。便处汤药。昔贤所
讥。于今为甚。以是识病之真。而不谬于毫厘千里之介。抑又难矣。予将举以告子之书者。
〔亡名氏静耘斋集验方〕八卷 未见
〔容山德轩氏普济应验良方〕一卷 存
自序曰。静耘斋集验方八卷。救治良法。无证不备。行世已久。人所共珍。今于原集中。择取简要诸方。录
为一册。间有根据他书补入者。要皆屡经效验之方。汇付枣梨。量力印送。知乐善君子。见是书。其利济之心。不
能自已。当必同印广施。遍救疾苦。则斯刻之幸也。时嘉庆己未仲春。
〔叶氏(慕樵)平易〕四卷 存
自序曰。昔新建曹鞠庵先生汇辑万方类编。分一百七门。计症三千四百七十又九。得方一万一千七百有奇。
别类分门。了如指掌。可谓殚尽心力。利天下后世者不小矣。顾其中有一证而二三方者。亦有多至数十方者。搜
罗既富。卷帙不少。在学识既优之士。固以多多为善。若如其才浅见迂。徒使望洋惊叹。且猛毒之药。势如野狼虎。
证不灼见。方难遽旌。今惟就外科女科儿科等门。候有定者。治亦易定。故摘录较广。以备博采。至于疟疾中风
伤寒等门。皆系内证。骤难辨别。且虚实变迁,移步换影。若备录之。恐拘于成法。毫厘之失。贻误匪轻。故仅
从简略。并以内经知要。颐生微论。传忠录。经验良方等书。采摘一二。加载卷内。间附以制治方法。大抵皆平
稳无害。简易可从者。义取平易。名曰平易方。惟是蠡测管窥。未臻完善。仍俟高明。随证变通。随方参证云尔。
嘉庆九年。岁次甲子。春二月朔日。武林香HT 自序。
按:上述内容见于刘嗣宗《温疫论类编》的序言。
〔唐大烈(字立三)《吴医汇讲》〕十卷 存世
自序说:我考察炎帝神农氏记载药物,首先垂示了《本草》的经典;云瑞命名官职,开启了《灵兰秘典》的书册。师承流传历代,各家各自建立学术言论;流派繁衍至今,尤其擅长搜集记录。篁南江氏有分类医案的编纂,东逸罗君有汇总精华的选择。正因为渊源有自,所以记述的人很多。况且我们吴地是文献昌盛之邦,也是良医荟萃之地。韩姓兄弟,享有卢医、扁鹊般的声誉;葛氏父子,继承张仲景、刘河间的学问。新甫启东二十位子侄,前朝的著述已经繁多;生洲、路玉诸位公卿,圣代的阐扬也很多。《印机草》,让人认识到元仪临证时的慎重;《读书记》,让人知道在泾学业的深沉。凡这些各自成书,出自诸家的见解。康熙年间,有过君绎之者,收集众贤的治疗案例,合刻为一本书,名叫《吴中医案》。这又是片善必录,一艺必用,旁搜博采而成的著作。广泛罗列有效成果,固然为了记录乡先辈的典型,而各抒己见,也是为了证明各位君子的造诣功力。何况精通此业者,高才之士不少;明晓其理者,卓识自然众多。隐藏才华,不缺乏枕中之秘;灵机妙绪,岂缺少囊底之珍?凡是蕴藏的知识,怎能忍心惋惜?我谨仿照《吴中医案》的旧版,重新编辑《吴医汇讲》的新编。深奥的意义显明的言辞,统一用来求教;长篇短节,一并不拘泥于形式。如果能追随前人的步伐,期望当仁不让。于是秉持坚定的志向,不祈求光辉耀眼,共同表达深思,互相欣赏新奇。或者疏漏往日的训诫,既然发掘覆盖并摘取微义;或者出于匠心独裁,尤其领会新颖并标新立异。诠释玉版的秘要,欣喜符合丽泽的占验;索求金匮的真言,都契合盍簪的喜庆。不要说禁方三十种,独推孙思邈得到其奇妙;须知《肘后备急方》四编,不只是抱朴子穷尽其底蕴。纵然酿花为蜜,未免有书癖的讥讽;但集腋成裘,足以弥补艺林的缺憾。乾隆壬子年仲秋,长洲唐大烈立三氏书写于问心草堂。
〔武夷应道人秘传诸病药方〕一卷 存世
〔赵学敏《医林集腋》〕十六卷 未见
〔养素园传信方〕六卷 未见
按:上述内容见于汇刻书目。
〔沈丹彩《医谱》〕未见
钱大昕作序说:沈子丹彩,是我们县里的世家大族。年轻时放弃科举毕业,独自专心研究医方、五行、壬遁之术,都有神妙的理解。他又认为占卜筮卦的失误,仅仅止于不吉利;只有方药主要在于对症治病。病的名称相同,但有的感受于外邪,有的损伤于内因,有的实证适宜泻法,有的虚证适宜补法。在疑似之间,毫厘之差,结果千里之远。学习医学耗费人力,造成的祸害尤为剧烈。于是广泛涉猎古今方书,分类采集编辑,辨别受病的源头,从而掌握制方的用途,编写了《医谱》若干卷。完成后,准备交付刻印,并嘱托我说一句话作为序言。我又对丹彩说:你也知道相马的说法吗?从前伯乐向秦穆公推荐九方皋,穆公派他去寻找好马。三个月后回来,报告说:找到了。那匹马是母马且黄色。派人去取回,却是公马且黑色。召来伯乐责备他说:你所让找马的人,连毛色、性别都不知道,又怎么能懂马呢?伯乐感叹叹息说:他的技艺竟然到了这种地步吗?九方皋所观察的,是天机啊。他得到精髓而忽略粗浅,关注内在而忽略外在。看他所应该看的,而不看他所不应该看的。这就是他胜过我千万倍的原因。汉人马援年轻时拜杨子阿为师,学习相骨法。等到征讨交趾时,得到骆越铜鼓,铸成马式。他认为传闻不如亲眼所见,看影子不如观察实物。于是依据仪氏的髀骨,中帛氏的口齿,谢氏的嘴唇,丁氏的身中比例,备齐这几家的骨相作为法式。伯乐对于马,只是观察其天机罢了,毛色性别甚至来不及分辨,而伏波将军马援却斤斤计较于口齿唇髀,支节分寸,一一取其相似。这与只看皮相的人有什么区别呢?然而伯乐世间不常有,而相马的方法不可不传承。想要使物尽其才,人借其用,骅骝不要被困于拉盐车,驽蹇不要混入上等的马匹行列。除了伏波将军的铜马式,还能看什么呢?古人根据石药的寒温属性,衡量疾病的深浅,辨别五苦六辛,调配水火之剂,以通闭解结,于是有了十一家的经方。这就像伏波将军相马有法式一样。而善于行医的人又说:上医治在诊脉,脉理的妙处不可传授。只罗列方剂,对世道无益。这就是伯乐所说的,观察天机,不见其所不应见的东西。现在你既精通察脉,洞见垣一方,又集合古今诊治之法,编成谱系以示后人。这是否符合伏波将军的心意呢?虽然如此,切寸口不及尺部,握手不足足部,相对片刻,便开汤药,这是昔贤所讥讽的,如今更为严重。以此认识疾病的真相,而不谬于毫厘千里的界限,又更加困难了。我将把这些举出来告诉你,作为你书的序言。
〔无名氏《静耘斋集验方》〕八卷 未见
〔容山德轩氏《普济应验良方》〕一卷 存世
自序说:《静耘斋集验方》八卷,救治的良好方法,没有病症不具备的。流行于世已久,人们共同珍视。现在在原集中,选取简要的各首方剂,录入为一册。间或有根据其他书籍补入的,都是屡经验证有效的方剂,汇集付梓,量力印送。希望乐善君子,见到这本书,那种利济之心,不能自已,应当必定共同印行广施,遍救疾苦,那么这次刻印就是幸运的了。时值嘉庆己未年仲春。
〔叶慕樵《平易方》〕四卷 存世
自序说:以前新建曹鞠庵先生汇总编辑万方类编,分一百零七门,计症三千四百七十九种,得方一万一千七百多首。别类分门,了如指掌,可以说是尽心竭力,利于天下后世,贡献不小。其中有一证而二三方者,也有多至数十方者。搜集既丰富,卷帙也不少。在学识优秀的士人看来,多多益善;但如果像我才浅见迂,徒然使人望洋兴叹。而且猛毒之药,势如野狼虎,证候不灼见,方剂难以确立。现在只就外科、女科、儿科等门类,候有定者,治亦易定,所以摘录较广,以备博采。至于疟疾、中风、伤寒等门类,皆属内科证候,骤然难辨别,且虚实变迁,移步换影,若全部收录,恐怕拘泥于成法,毫厘之失,贻误匪轻。所以仅从简略,并以内经知要、颐生微论、传忠录、经验良方等书,采摘一二,加载卷内。间附以制治方法,大抵皆平稳无害,简易可从者。义取平易,名叫《平易方》。只是蠡测管窥,未臻完善,仍等待高明之士,随证变通,随方参证而已。嘉庆九年,岁次甲子,春二月朔日,武林香巘自序。
Translation:
Note: The above content appears in the preface of Liu Sizong's *Wen Yi Lun Lei Bian* (Classified Compilation on Warm Epidemic Diseases).
[Tang Daliè (styled Lisan) *Wu Yi Hui Jiang* (Collected Lectures of Wu Physicians)] Ten volumes. Extant.
Preface by the author states: I have investigated how Yan Di (Shennong, Divine Farmer) recorded substances, first establishing the classic of *Ben Cao* (Materia Medica); Yun Rui named official positions, initiating the archives of *Ling Lan* (Spiritual Orchid). Transmission through generations established various schools of thought; lineages evolved to the present, excelling especially in collection and recording. Jiang of Huangnan compiled classified medical cases; Luo of Dongyi selected collected essences. Precisely because origins are distinct, there are many chroniclers. Moreover, our Wu region is a land of abundant literature and a domain where excellent physicians gather. The Han brothers enjoyed reputations comparable to Lu Yi (Bian Que); the Ge father and son inherited the learning of Zhang Zhongjing and Liu Wansu. The twenty descendants of Xinpu Qidong had prolific writings in previous dynasties; Shengzhou, Luyu, and other gentlemen made significant contributions in the current era. *Yin Ji Cao* reveals Yuan Yi’s caution in clinical practice; *Du Shu Ji* shows Zai Jing’s profound scholarship. All these works stand alone, originating from various scholars' perspectives. During the Kangxi reign, Guo Jun Yizhi collected the treatment records of many sages and carved them into a book titled *Wu Yi Zhong An* (Medical Cases of Wu Physicians). This was again a work compiled by collecting every minor merit and utilizing every skill, searching widely and gathering extensively. Broadly listing effective results serves not only to record the models of local ancestors but also to demonstrate the achievements of gentlemen through their own discussions. Furthermore, those who master this profession possess considerable talent, and those who understand its principles naturally have outstanding insights. Those who hide their brilliance do not lack secrets kept in pillows; spiritual ingenuity and subtle thoughts are certainly not devoid of treasures in bags. All such hidden knowledge, how could it be bearable to regret? I have carefully followed the old edition of *Wu Yi Zhong An* to compile a new edition of *Wu Yi Hui Jiang*. Profound meanings and explicit words are unified for seeking instruction; long passages and short sections are treated without rigid constraints. If one can follow in the footsteps of predecessors, one should expect to not yield when duty calls. Thus, holding firm to one's will, not seeking glory, expressing deep thought together, and appreciating novelty mutually. Whether omitting past teachings to uncover covered truths and extract subtleties, or originating from independent judgment to grasp newness and mark differences, interpreting the secrets of jade plates with joy matching the divination of Lize, and seeking true words from the Golden Casket, all align with the celebration of gathering. Do not say that among thirty secret prescriptions, Sun Simiao alone obtained the wonder; know that the four compilations of *Zhou Hou Bei Ji Fang* (Handbook of Prescriptions for Emergencies) are not merely Pao Pu Zi exhausting their depth. Although turning flowers into honey might invite criticism of bibliomania, collecting armpit fur to make a robe suffices to fill gaps in the forest of arts. Mid-Autumn of Renzi year in Qianlong era, Tang Daliè Lisan wrote at Wenxin Caotang in Changzhou.
[Wuyi Ying Daoren Secretly Transcribed Prescription for Various Diseases] One volume. Extant.
[Zhao Xuemin *Yi Lin Ji Ye* (Collecting Scraps from the Medical Forest)] Sixteen volumes. Not seen.
[Yang Suyuan Chuan Xin Fang] Six volumes. Not seen.
Note: The above appears in the Catalogue of Collected Editions.
[Shen Dancai *Yi Pu* (Medical Canon/Chart)] Not seen.
Preface by Qian Daxin states: Shen Dancai belongs to a prominent family in our county. In his youth, he abandoned the civil service examination path and devoted himself exclusively to medical formulas, Five Elements, and Ren-Dun divination techniques, possessing divine understanding. He believed that the error of divination lies only in misfortune, whereas medicines primarily aim to treat diseases. Disease names may be the same, yet some arise from external pathogens, others from internal injury; some excess conditions require purging, while deficiency conditions require tonifying. Between similarity and difference, a hair's breadth leads to a thousand miles. Studying medicine consumes human effort and causes particularly severe harm. Therefore, he broadly studied ancient and modern medical texts, classified and collected them, distinguished the sources of disease, and thereby mastered the application of prescription formulation, creating several volumes of *Yi Pu*. Upon completion, he prepared to have it printed and asked me to write a preface. I replied to Dancai: Do you know the saying about judging horses? In the past, Bo Le recommended Jiu Fang Gao to Duke Mu of Qin. The Duke sent him to find a fine horse. Three months later, he returned and reported: "I found it." It was a mare and yellow. When the envoy went to fetch it, it turned out to be a stallion and black. The Duke summoned Bo Le to reprimand him, saying: "The man you sent to find a horse couldn't even tell color or gender, how could he know horses?" Bo Le sighed deeply and said: "Has his skill reached such a level? What Jiu Fang Gao observes is the heavenly mechanism. He grasps the essence and forgets the coarse; focuses on the interior and forgets the exterior. He sees what he needs to see and ignores what he does not need to see. This is why he surpasses me by thousands." Ma Yuan of the Han Dynasty studied bone-judging under Yang Zi'a in his youth. When campaigning in Jiaozhi, he obtained a bronze drum from the Luoyue people and cast it into a horse model. He believed that hearing reports is inferior to seeing with one's own eyes, and viewing shadows is inferior to observing forms. Thus, based on Yi Shi's thigh bones, Zhongbo Shi's teeth, Xie Shi's lips, and Ding Shi's body proportions, he prepared these several families' bone structures as standards. Bo Le, regarding horses, observed only their heavenly mechanism, not bothering to distinguish color or gender. Yet Fubo General (Ma Yuan) haggled over teeth, lips, and thighs, measuring joints inch by inch, seeking exact resemblance. How is this different from superficial observers? However, Bo Les are rare in the world, yet the method of judging horses must be transmitted. To let things reach their full potential and people utilize them effectively, so that swift horses are not trapped pulling salt carts and inferior horses do not mix with superior ones, what else is there to observe besides the Bronze Horse Model of Fubo? Ancients used the cold and warm properties of stones and herbs, measured the depth of diseases, distinguished five bitter and six pungent flavors, formulated water and fire agents, to open blockages and resolve knots, thus giving rise to eleven schools of classical prescriptions. This is like Fubo having a standard for judging horses. But good physicians also say: The highest physician focuses on pulse diagnosis; the subtlety of pulses cannot be transmitted. Listing prescriptions alone is useless to the world. This is what Bo Le meant by observing the heavenly mechanism and ignoring what should not be seen. Now, since you are proficient in pulse diagnosis, seeing clearly within the walls, and have collected methods of diagnosis and treatment from ancient and modern times to create a chart for future generations, does this align with the intent of Fubo? Nevertheless, measuring the cun without reaching the chi, shaking hands without reaching the feet, facing each other for a moment and then prescribing decoctions—this was criticized by former sages and is even more prevalent today. To recognize the truth of diseases and avoid errors of a hair's breadth leading to a thousand miles is extremely difficult. I offer these remarks for your book.
[Anonymous *Jingyun Zhai Ji Yan Fang* (Verified Prescriptions from Jingyun Studio)] Eight volumes. Not seen.
[Rongshan Dexianshi *Pu Ji Ying Yan Liang Fang* (Universal Benefit Verified Good Prescriptions)] One volume. Extant.
Preface by the author states: *Jingyun Zhai Ji Yan Fang*, eight volumes, contains excellent rescue methods covering all diseases. It has been circulated for a long time and is highly valued by people. Now, from the original collection, I have selected concise prescriptions and recorded them in one booklet. Some are added based on other books, but they are all prescriptions verified multiple times. They are compiled and printed, distributed according to capacity. I hope benevolent gentlemen who see this book will feel an irresistible desire to benefit others and surely print and distribute it widely to relieve suffering. Then this printing will be fortunate. Mid-Spring of Jiwu year in Jiaqing era.
[Ye Muqiao *Ping Yi Fang* (Simple and Easy Prescriptions)] Four volumes. Extant.
Preface by the author states: Previously, Mr. Cao Ju'an of Xinjian compiled and edited ten thousand prescriptions classified into categories, divided into 107 sections, accounting for 3,479 symptoms and obtaining over 11,700 prescriptions. Classified and categorized, clear as palm lines, one could say he exhausted his heart and efforts, benefiting the world and future generations significantly. However, among them, some symptoms had two or three prescriptions, and some had dozens. The collection was rich, and the volumes were numerous. For scholars with excellent knowledge, more is indeed better; but for someone with shallow talent and rigid views like myself, it would only cause awe-struck sighing. Moreover, potent toxic drugs are fierce like wild wolves and tigers; if the syndrome is not clearly perceived, the prescription is hard to establish. Now, I only select from Surgery, Gynecology, and Pediatrics, where patterns are fixed and treatments are easier to determine, so the excerpts are broader to prepare for extensive collection. As for Malaria, Stroke, and Cold Damage, these belong to internal syndromes, which are suddenly difficult to distinguish, and changes between deficiency and excess shift rapidly. If fully recorded, one might be constrained by established methods, and a slight error could cause serious delay. Therefore, I kept them brief, and extracted a few items from *Neijing Zhi Yao* (Essentials of the Inner Canon), *Yisheng Weilun* (Subtle Discussions on Nourishing Life), *Chuanzhong Lu* (Records of Passing Truth), and *Jingyan Liangfang* (Experienced Good Prescriptions), adding them to the volumes. Interspersed with control and treatment methods, generally all are safe, harmless, simple, and easy to follow. The principle takes simplicity, hence named *Ping Yi Fang*. However, my understanding is limited like measuring the sea with a gourd or peeping through a tube, far from perfect. I still await experts to adapt according to syndromes and cross-reference according to prescriptions. First day of the second month of spring, Jiazi year, ninth year of Jiaqing, Xiangyan of Wulin wrote the preface.