《难经》曰∶温病之脉,行在诸经,不知何经之动,随其经之所在而取之。
如太阳证头疼恶寒,汗下后过经不愈,诊得尺寸俱浮者,太阳病温也。
过时而发,不在表也,已经汗下,亦不在表也。经曰∶不恶寒而反渴者温病也。明其热自内达外,无表证明矣。
按∶伤寒传经,由腑入脏,由阳入阴。温病不传经,止中一二经,或乘某经火,或乘某经虚,被春时寒气所中,自
内
发外,而作寒热等证,或中腑则腑病,或中脏则脏病,不论日期,始终惟此一二经。《内经》言惟经所动,随经而
取,自是明明断案,节庵分经良是,而以过太阳经不传别经,定为温病,此辨别寒温之口诀,所当佩服者。
论曰∶恶寒否乎?曰伤寒自冬月风寒而成,外则有恶寒恶风之证,既名为温,则无此证矣。曰∶然则子之言何所据
乎?
曰∶据乎经耳。经曰∶太阳病,发热不恶寒而渴者,温病也。不恶寒则病非因外来,渴则明其自内达
表。
按∶冬月伤寒,由于外感而恶寒是矣。曰∶温证不恶寒非也。盖温证缘阳气发畅,为春时风寒所迫,虽系内
热,亦由外感,故亦有恶寒等证,岂独温即暑病?亦有此证,盖暑属外火伤于脏腑,内外炎炎,故热极战栗而成
恶寒,医不知,遂为伤寒,不可不详辨也。
论曰∶伤暑与伤寒俱有热,若误作伤寒治之则不可。盖寒伤形,热伤气,伤寒则外感寒而脉浮紧,伤暑则不恶
寒而脉虚,此为异耳。经云∶脉盛身寒,得之伤寒,脉虚身热,得之伤暑,治宜小柴胡汤,渴加石膏、知母,或
人参白虎汤。天久淫雨,湿令大行,苍术白虎汤。若元气素弱,而伤之重者,清暑益气汤治之。
夫伤寒二字,盖冬时天气严寒,以水冰地冻,而成杀厉之气,人触犯之,实时病者为伤寒,乃有恶寒头疼发热
之证,故用麻黄、桂枝发散表中寒邪,自然热退身凉,有何变证?如或头疼恶寒,表证皆除,而反见谵语怕热燥
渴,大便闭者,以法下之,大便通而热愈,有何怪证?其余春夏秋三时,虽有恶寒身热,头疼亦微即为感冒,非时暴
寒之轻,非比冬时气正伤寒为重也。如冬感寒不即病,伏藏于肌肤,至春夏秋时,其伏寒各随时气改变为温为热
者,因温暑将发,又受暴寒,故春变为温病,既变之后,不得复言其为寒矣,所以仲景有云∶发热不恶寒而渴者,其
理可见,温病也,暑病亦然,比之温病,尤加热不恶寒,则病非外来,渴则明其热自内达表,无表证明矣。治温暑大
抵不宜发汗,过时而发,不在表也。其伏寒至夏,又感冒寒变为暑病,暑病者,即热病也。取夏火当权而言暑字,缘其
温热二证,从冬时伏寒所化,总曰伤寒。所发之时既异,治之不可混也,若言四时俱是正伤寒者非也。此三者,
皆用辛凉之剂以解之,若将冬时正伤寒之药通治之,定杀人矣。辛凉羌活冲和汤是也,兼能代大青龙汤治伤寒见风,伤
风见寒为至稳,一方可代三方危险之药,如垣夷其神乎哉!世俗皆所未知也。若表解其里证具者,亦以法下
之无惑,又伤寒下后,过经不愈者,亦温病也。已经汗下,亦不在表也,随病制宜。凡有辛苦劳役之人,有患头疼恶寒
身热,加之骨腿酸疼,微渴自汗,脉虽浮大而无力,此为劳力感寒,用补中益气辛温之剂为良。经云∶温能除
大热,正此谓也。若当和解者,即以小柴胡加减和之,下证见者,即以本方加大黄微利之,切勿过用猛烈,其害非细。
若初病无身热,无头疼,便就怕寒厥冷,腹痛呕吐泄泻,脉来沉迟无力,此为直中寒证,宜温之,而不宜汗下
也。疫疠者,皆时行不正之气,老幼传染相同者是也。缘人不近秽气,免伤真气,若近秽气,有伤正气,故病相传染,
正如墙壁固,贼人不敢入,正气盛,邪气不敢侵,正气既虚,邪得乘机而入。与前温暑治又不同,表证见者,人参
败毒散;半表半里证者,小柴胡;里证具者,大柴胡下之。无以脉诊,以平为期,与其疟痢等证,亦时疫也,照常法例
治之。
按∶此辨伤寒伤暑,最为吃紧,广度慈航,一披卷而了然者,当熟读精思,方得其解,斟酌用之,方得其妙。
《难经》说:温病的脉象,流行于各条经脉,不知道是哪条经脉发生病变,就根据该经脉所在的位置进行诊治。
如果是太阳病证,出现头痛、恶寒,经过发汗或攻下治疗后,病情超过一经的传变周期仍未痊愈,诊察发现寸口和尺口的脉象都浮,这是太阳病温证。
如果过了发病时节才发作,说明病邪不在体表;既然已经用过发汗或攻下法,也说明病邪不在体表。医经说:“不恶寒反而口渴的是温病。”这明确表明热邪是从内部达于外部,没有表证的证据了。
按语:伤寒的传经规律,是由腑传入脏,由阳经传入阴经。温病不遵循这种传经规律,只涉及一两条经脉,或者是受到某条经脉火邪的影响,或者是乘虚侵袭某条经脉虚弱之处,被春季的寒气所中,从内部发出于外部,从而产生寒热等症状。如果侵犯腑,则表现为腑病;如果侵犯脏,则表现为脏病。不论经过多少天,始终只局限于这一两条经脉。《内经》说只要看哪条经脉受动,就随该经脉进行诊治,这已经是明确的定论。节庵(明代医家)将病分经论治是正确的,但他认为“过了太阳经而不传变到其他经”就定为温病,这是辨别伤寒与温病的关键口诀,应当佩服。
论述说:有没有恶寒的症状呢?回答说:伤寒是由于冬季的风寒邪气引起的,体外有恶寒、恶风的症状。既然命名为温病,就不应该有这些症状。问:那么你所说的依据是什么呢?
答:依据医经。医经说:“太阳病,发热但不恶寒而且口渴的,是温病。”不恶寒说明病不是因外感引起,口渴明确表明热邪从内部达于体表。
按语:冬季的伤寒,由于外感邪气而出现恶寒,这是对的。但说温证不恶寒是不对的。大概温证是因为阳气发散通畅,被春季的风寒所逼迫,虽然属于内热,但也由外感引起,所以也有恶寒等症状。难道只有暑病才有这个症状吗?暑病也是这样的。暑属于外火伤害脏腑,内外火热炽盛,所以热极导致战栗而成为恶寒。医生如果不了解这一点,就会误认为是伤寒,不可不详细辨别。
论述说:伤暑与伤寒都有发热,如果误当作伤寒治疗就不行了。大概寒邪损伤形体,热邪损伤气机。伤寒则是外感寒邪而脉象浮紧;伤暑则不恶寒而脉象虚软,这就是区别。医经说:“脉象盛大而身体寒冷的,得自伤寒;脉象虚软而身体发热的,得自伤暑。”治疗适宜用小柴胡汤,口渴加石膏、知母,或者用人参白虎汤。如果天空久雨不停,湿气盛行,用苍术白虎汤。如果元气素来虚弱,且受伤严重的,用清暑益气汤治疗。
所谓“伤寒”二字,大概是指冬季天气严寒,水结冰地冻,形成杀厉之气,人触犯它,随即发病的就是伤寒,会有恶寒、头疼、发热等症状,所以用麻黄、桂枝发散体表的寒邪,自然热退身凉,有什么变证呢?如果头疼恶寒等表证都已经消除,反而出现谵语、怕热、烦躁口渴、大便闭塞的情况,用攻下的方法治疗,大便通畅后热势更重,又有什么奇怪的病症呢?其余春、夏、秋三个季节,虽然有恶寒身热、头疼,但头疼轻微,这属于感冒,是非时暴寒的轻症,不像冬季的正伤寒那样严重。如果在冬季感受寒邪没有立即发病,潜伏在肌肤之间,到了春夏秋季节,潜伏的寒邪随着当时的气候改变转化为温病或热病。因为温暑将要发作,又受到暴寒侵袭,所以在春季变为温病。一旦转化之后,就不能再说它是寒邪了。所以张仲景说:“发热不恶寒而口渴的,其理可见,是温病。”暑病也是如此,比之温病,更加加热而不恶寒,说明病非外来,口渴表明热自内达表,没有表证的证据了。治疗温暑大体上不宜发汗,过了时节发作,病邪不在体表。那些潜伏的寒邪到了夏季,又感冒寒邪而变为暑病。暑病,就是热病。取夏季火气当权而言“暑”字,因为温热两种证候,都是从冬季潜伏的寒邪所化生,总称为伤寒。既然发病的时间不同,治疗不可混淆。如果说四季都是正伤寒,那是不对的。这三者(温、热、暑),都用辛凉的药剂来解表。如果用冬季正伤寒的药物通用治疗,一定会致人死亡。辛凉羌活冲和汤就是这样的方剂,兼能代替大青龙汤治疗伤寒见风、伤风见寒的情况,最为稳妥,一方可以代替三方危险的药物,如垣夷(指李东垣或相关医家,此处指代高明医术)的神妙啊!世俗之人都不知道这些。如果表证解除而里证具备的,也用攻下的方法治疗,没有疑惑。另外,伤寒攻下后,超过传经周期仍未痊愈的,也是温病。既然已经发汗或攻下,病邪也不在体表,应根据病情制定治疗方法。凡是从事辛苦劳役的人,患上头疼、恶寒、身热,加上骨腿酸疼,微渴、自汗,脉象虽然浮大但无力,这是劳力感寒,用补中益气汤这类辛温的药剂为好。医经说:“温能除大热”,正是说的这个道理。如果应当和解的,就用小柴胡汤加减来和解;出现攻下适应证的,就用本方加大黄轻微通利,切勿过度使用猛烈药物,危害不小。如果初起没有身热、没有头疼,就怕冷厥冷,腹痛呕吐泄泻,脉象沉迟无力,这是直中寒证,适宜温补,而不宜发汗或攻下。疫疠病,都是时行不正之气,老幼传染症状相同。因为人不接触秽浊之气,就能避免损伤真气;如果接触秽浊之气,就会损伤正气,所以疾病相互传染。正如墙壁坚固,贼人不敢进入;正气旺盛,邪气不敢侵犯;正气既然虚弱,邪气就乘机而入。这与前面温暑的治疗又不同。出现表证的,用人参败毒散;半表半里证的,用小柴胡汤;里证具备的,用大柴胡汤攻下。如果没有脉诊依据,以平复为准则。至于疟疾、痢疾等证,也是时疫,照常法例治疗。
按语:这里辨析伤寒与伤暑,最为关键,如同广度慈航(比喻普度众生),翻开书卷就能明白的人,应当熟读精思,才能理解其中的奥妙,斟酌运用,才能掌握其精髓。
According to the *Nan Jing* (Classic of Difficult Issues): The pulse of warm disease circulates through the various meridians. If it is unknown which meridian is affected, treatment should be directed according to the location of the affected meridian.
If there are symptoms of the Taiyang syndrome (Taiyang Meridian Syndrome), such as headache and aversion to cold, and after sweating or purging therapies, the condition persists beyond the transmission cycle of one meridian, and the pulse at both the cun (inch) and chi (cubit) positions is floating, this is Warm Disease of the Taiyang channel.
If the disease manifests after the appropriate season has passed, the pathogen is not in the exterior. Since sweating or purging therapies have already been applied, the pathogen is also not in the exterior. The classics state: "Those who do not have aversion to cold but instead have thirst suffer from warm disease." This clearly indicates that the heat originates internally and reaches the exterior, proving the absence of exterior syndrome evidence.
Commentary: In cold damage (Shanghan), the transmission of disease proceeds from the fu organs to the zang organs, and from yang meridians to yin meridians. Warm disease does not follow this pattern of transmission; it affects only one or two meridians. It may be due to the fire pathogen of a specific meridian, or because the pathogen takes advantage of deficiency in a specific meridian. Being struck by cold qi in spring, the pathogen emerges from the interior to the exterior, causing symptoms such as alternating chills and fever. If it strikes the fu organs, it causes fu organ disease; if it strikes the zang organs, it causes zang organ disease. Regardless of the number of days elapsed, it remains confined to these one or two meridians. The *Nei Jing* (Inner Canon) states that one should observe which meridian is disturbed and treat accordingly; this is a clear verdict. Jie'an's method of differentiating diseases by meridian is correct. However, defining warm disease as "passing the Taiyang meridian without transmitting to other meridians" is a key principle for distinguishing between cold damage and warm disease, which deserves admiration.
Discussion: Is there aversion to cold? Answer: Cold damage arises from wind-cold in winter, presenting with external symptoms of aversion to cold and aversion to wind. Since it is named warm disease, these symptoms should be absent. Question: On what basis do you say this? Answer: Based on the classics. The classics state: "In Taiyang disease, if there is fever but no aversion to cold, accompanied by thirst, it is warm disease." No aversion to cold indicates the disease is not caused by external invasion; thirst clearly indicates heat reaching the surface from the interior.
Commentary: Winter cold damage presents with aversion to cold due to external invasion, which is correct. However, stating that warm disease never presents with aversion to cold is incorrect. Generally, warm disease occurs when yang qi is freely circulating but is constrained by spring wind-cold. Although it involves internal heat, it is also triggered by external factors, thus presenting with symptoms like aversion to cold. Does only summerheat present with this symptom? Summerheat disease also presents this way. Summerheat is an external fire pathogen injuring the zang-fu organs, causing intense heat inside and out. Extreme heat can lead to shivering, manifesting as aversion to cold. If physicians do not understand this, they may misdiagnose it as cold damage; careful differentiation is essential.
Discussion: Both summerheat injury and cold damage involve fever. Misdiagnosing summerheat as cold damage is inadvisable. Generally, cold damages the form (body structure), while heat damages qi. In cold damage, external cold invasion results in a floating and tight pulse. In summerheat injury, there is no aversion to cold, and the pulse is deficient/weak. This is the distinction. The classics state: "Pulse is full/excessive with body cold indicates cold damage; pulse is weak with body heat indicates summerheat injury." Treatment should use Xiao Chai Hu Tang (Minor Bupleurum Decoction). If thirsty, add Shigao (Gypsum Fibrosum) and Zhimu (Anemarrhenae Rhizoma), or use Renshen Baihu Tang (Ginseng White Tiger Decoction). If prolonged rain causes excessive dampness, use Cangzhu Baihu Tang (Atractylodis Rhizoma White Tiger Decoction). If the vital qi is inherently weak and the injury is severe, use Qingshu Yiqi Tang (Clear Summerheat and Boost Qi Decoction).
The term "cold damage" generally refers to the severe cold of winter, where water freezes and ice forms, creating a killing/cruel qi. When people are exposed to it and fall ill immediately, it is called cold damage, characterized by aversion to cold, headache, and fever. Therefore, Mahuang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) or Guizhi Tang (Cinnamon Twig Decoction) are used to disperse exterior cold pathogens, naturally resolving fever and cooling the body. Are there any complications? If headache and aversion to cold (exterior signs) are resolved, but delirium, fear of heat, restlessness, thirst, and constipation appear, purgation therapy should be used. If stool becomes unblocked but heat worsens, what strange complication is this? In spring, summer, and autumn, even if there is aversion to cold, fever, and mild headache, it is considered a common cold (ganmao), a mild case of non-seasonal sudden cold, not as severe as true winter cold damage. If cold is contracted in winter but does not manifest immediately, it lies latent in the skin and muscles. In spring, summer, or autumn, this latent cold transforms into warm disease or heat disease depending on the seasonal qi. Because warm or summerheat conditions are about to emerge, exposure to sudden cold triggers the transformation into warm disease in spring. Once transformed, it cannot be referred to as cold again. Thus, Zhang Zhongjing stated: "Fever without aversion to cold and with thirst indicates warm disease." Summerheat disease is similar; compared to warm disease, it involves more intense heat without aversion to cold, indicating the pathogen is not external, and thirst indicates heat originating internally and reaching the exterior, confirming no exterior syndrome. Treatment for warm and summerheat diseases generally prohibits sweating therapy, especially if onset is delayed, as the pathogen is no longer in the exterior. Latent cold transforming into summerheat in summer is essentially heat disease. The term "summerheat" is derived from the dominance of summer fire qi. Since warm and heat syndromes originate from latent winter cold, they are collectively termed cold damage. However, since the time of onset differs, treatments must not be confused. Claiming all four seasons involve true cold damage is incorrect. These three categories (warm, heat, summerheat) should be treated with acrid-cool agents. Using winter cold damage medications universally would be fatal. Xinqiang Huozhe Tang (Acrid Cool Notopterygium and Heteromorpha Decoction) is suitable; it can also substitute Da Qinglong Tang (Major Green Dragon Decoction) for treating cold damage complicated by wind or wind-cold injury, providing stability. One formula replaces three dangerous ones. Such efficacy is miraculous! The layperson is unaware of this. If the exterior is resolved but interior signs remain, purgation is appropriate without doubt. Furthermore, if cold damage persists after purging beyond the transmission cycle, it becomes warm disease. Having undergone sweating or purging, the pathogen is no longer in the exterior; treatment must adapt to the specific condition. For individuals engaged in hard labor, symptoms of headache, aversion to cold, fever, soreness in bones and legs, slight thirst, spontaneous sweating, and a floating, large but weak pulse indicate cold injury due to labor. Bu Zhong Yi Qi Tang (Tonify the Middle and Augment the Qi Decoction), an acrid-warm formula, is beneficial. The classics state: "Warmth can remove great heat," referring to this scenario. For cases requiring harmonization, modify Xiao Chai Hu Tang. If purgation indications appear, add Dahuang (Rhei Radix et Rhizoma) to gently promote bowel movement. Avoid overly harsh medicines, as the harm is significant. If initial symptoms lack fever and headache, but present with aversion to cold, cold limbs, abdominal pain, vomiting, diarrhea, and a deep, slow, weak pulse, this is direct transmission of cold (zhizhong han zheng). It requires warming therapy, not sweating or purging. Epidemic pestilence (yili) is caused by abnormal seasonal qi, affecting old and young similarly through contagion. Avoiding foul odors prevents damage to true qi; exposure damages righteous qi, leading to contagion. Just as a strong wall keeps thieves out, strong righteous qi repels pathogens; when righteous qi is weak, pathogens enter opportunistically. Treatment differs from warm/summerheat. With exterior signs, use Renshen Baidu San (Ginseng Detoxification Powder); with half-exterior/half-interior signs, use Xiao Chai Hu Tang; with full interior signs, use Da Chai Hu Tang (Major Bupleurum Decoction) for purgation. Without pulse diagnosis, aim for balance. Malaria and dysentery are also epidemics; treat them according to standard methods.
Commentary: Differentiating cold damage from summerheat injury is crucial. It is like a boat saving lives; those who read and understand it clearly should study it carefully to grasp its essence and apply it judiciously.