Library

Typhoid (Shanghan) is not a strange disease. *Treatise on Cold Damage* (*Shanghan Lun*) is not a strange book. Zhang Zhongjing recorded what he observed in writing; it was not because this book already existed that people all over the world fell ill according to it.

Regarding the points of transformation among the Three Yin and Three Yang, predecessors often used rigid and stereotyped language, as if some dark spirit were directing the pathogenic factors. They could not explain how the transmission occurred. Readers must eliminate such subjective preconceptions. When reading each passage, one should imagine a patient present, deduce their pathogenesis and treatment principles, and then verify them with the text. One should not merely focus on textual arrangement.

First, one must distinguish what kind of disease typhoid is. This is a disease that occurs in all four seasons. However, in spring, summer, and autumn, there are often variations involving warmth, dampness, dryness, or wind. The climate is not purely cold, and the skin pores (Cou Li) are loose. Upon initial injury, two or three meridians may be affected simultaneously. After further transmission, all six meridians may be involved. Only in winter are the skin pores tight and dense. Cold pathogens must first injure the skin and gradually penetrate inward. Therefore, it is acceptable to say that the treatment methods for typhoid in winter differ from other seasons. However, it is incorrect to claim that there is no typhoid in the other three seasons. Zhang Zhongjing specifically discussed winter typhoid. Cases include those manifesting immediately in winter and those delayed until spring, which are often intermixed. He did not analyze whether those delayed manifestations in spring were also strictly cold diseases before transforming into heat. This differs from the principle in *Neijing*: "Injury by cold in winter leads to warm disease in spring."

Second, one must distinguish the meaning of "cold" and "heat" in *Treatise on Cold Damage*. "Cold" refers to the pathogenic qi of heaven and earth. "Heat" refers to the righteous qi of the human body. Constrained by cold pathogens, the righteous qi cannot diffuse and disperse, leading to stagnation and heat formation. This heat coexists with the cold pathogen; it is not that cold transforms into heat. This differs from warm-heat diseases, which are caused by heavenly and earthly heat pathogens. Once the cold pathogen dissipates, the heat should resolve as yang qi extends. If it does not resolve, it is because the righteous qi has been trapped for a long time, causing meridian stagnation and inability to circulate freely, or due to mismanagement.

Third, the concept of "transmission" must be understood flexibly. Pathogens do not have legs to walk or transform themselves uniformly. Whatever symptoms appear indicates which meridian is injured. For example, Shaoyang governs the circulation of body fluids; when fluids are scorched and dried, Shaoyang syndrome appears. Yangming governs the transport of residues; when residues become dry and bound, Yangming syndrome appears. Readers must ponder why headaches, vomiting, dizziness, and hypochondriac distension occur, and why constipation, tidal fever, and spontaneous sweating occur. One should not simply state, "The pathogen entered Shaoyang," or "The pathogen entered Yangming." One must seek explanations in qi transformation rather than being confined to anatomical locations.

Fourth, one must distinguish between initial injuries affecting the Three Yang, simultaneous infection (Liang Gan), and direct invasion (Zhi Zhong). The Taiyang meridian runs along the back and governs the exterior. At this stage, Yangming and Shaoyang are inevitably involved. *Neijing* states: "Injury at the nape enters Taiyang; injury at the face enters Yangming; injury at the cheek enters Shaoyang. Injury to yang flows into meridians; injury to yin flows into fu organs." Even in Zhang Zhongjing’s description of Taiyang wind-stroke with nasal congestion and dry retching, it is not solely Taiyang. Because the pathogen is at the great exterior, treatments generally involve Mahuang Tang, Guizhi Tang, or Gegen Tang, so there is no need to create excessive categories. Simultaneous infection and direct invasion occur due to deficiency of the person's yang qi or ferocity of the pathogen. Taiyang-Shaoyin and Yangming-Taiyin can both experience simultaneous infection. Shaoyang-Jueyin simultaneous infection is rare. Direct invasion is similar. Simultaneous infection of Shaoyang and Jueyin indicates extreme depletion of yang qi. The difference between direct invasion and simultaneous infection is that simultaneous infection involves equal pathogenic strength in one yin and one yang meridian, whereas direct invasion involves severe pathogenic excess in yin, leading to inevitable yang damage. However, yin-level illness is more urgent than simultaneous infection.

Fifth, one must recognize that injuring Ying (Nutritive Qi) and Wei (Defensive Qi) cannot be strictly separated. Zhang Zhongjing stated that wind injures Wei and cold injures Ying, briefly mentioned in Mahuang syndrome contexts, merely analyzing the predominance of wind or cold. His emphasis was on cold, presenting a connected argument rather than a flat statement. Moreover, wind-stroke presents with slow pulse and spontaneous sweating; sweat is Ying fluid. When Ying fluid leaks externally, Guizhi Tang replenishes Ying qi. Cold-damage presents with tight pulse and absence of sweating, where Wei qi is constrained by cold. Mahuang Tang is light and swift, penetrating Ying to reach Wei to open the exterior, acting primarily on Wei qi. How can one say wind only injures Wei and not Ying, or cold only injures Ying and not Wei? It is wrong to split these into two major outlines. Note: In winter, skin pores are closed, and cold penetrates gradually. Initial injury to the skin affects only the Qi level; dispersing it does not require sweating for the pathogen to dissipate. Secondary injury to muscles affects Body Fluids; pathogen exits with sweat. Tertiary injury to meridians enters the Blood level. Once in meridians, it may invade sinews and bones or disrupt the Triple Burner and occupy zang-fu organs. Some cases affect sinews and bones without entering meridians, hence Taiyin, Shaoyin, and Jueyin may still have exterior syndromes treatable by sweating. Once in meridians, it connects to zang-fu, making sweating insufficient alone. Before entering meridians, terms like Taiyang disease refer to regions, not specific meridians.

Sixth, one must understand the mechanism of cold-heat transmission and transformation. Initial injury is always cold. Long-standing cases may see cold pathogens sinking inward, indicating inherent internal cold. If cold leaves but heat remains, it indicates yin deficiency. Sinking cold pathogens cause diarrhea, known as transmission to Taiyin (Yin transmission). Essentially, this is sinking of Yangming. Subsequently, Shaoyang qi sinks, then Shaoyin qi sinks, until Jueyin liver qi sinks, leaving no vitality. Death invariably follows persistent diarrhea. If diarrhea stops before Jueyin sinking, death is avoided. If it stops after Jueyin sinking, accompanied by high breathing and vertigo, yin qi is exhausted. Unresolved heat leads to constipation and spontaneous sweating, known as transmission to Yangming (Yang transmission). By this stage, Taiyin fluids are depleted. Mismanagement depletes Shaoyin essence and Jueyin blood. Death invariably follows persistent constipation. Transmission usually stops at Yangming.

Seventh, the theory that "typhoid and warm diseases start differently but end similarly" should not be rigidly adhered to. This view only covers heat transmitting to Yangming. Cold transmitting to Taiyin is completely different. Typhoid has fatal cold syndromes but no fatal heat syndromes. Yangming interior excess is not fatal. Deaths result from mismanagement. Warm diseases, however, have natural, unchanging fatal heat syndromes.

Eighth, one must recognize differences between true and false presentations in combined diseases (He Bing) and concurrent diseases (Bing Bing). Predecessors’ distinctions were often forced. Simultaneous infection of two yang meridians is He Bing; spread from one to another is Bing Bing. Sometimes pathogens disturb a meridian without reaching it, presenting with deficiency-excess variations. For instance, a person with chronic stomach cold may develop bland taste and loose stools upon cold injury. A person with yin deficiency may develop wheezing and thirst due to internal heat stagnation. This is not necessarily transmission to Yangming or Taiyin. Dispersing cold resolves symptoms. In cases of severe internal deficiency, precautions are taken to prevent pathogen sinking.

Ninth, one must seek the reality of cold-heat qi transformation. The sequence of six-meridian transmission need not follow Zhang Zhongjing’s chapter order. Predecessors’ concepts of trans-meridian or interior-exterior transmission were too rigid. For example, Shaoyang governs meridian fluids; drying causes Shaoyang syndrome. Taiyin governs gastrointestinal fluids; drying causes Taiyin syndrome. Yangming governs gastrointestinal residues; binding causes Yangming syndrome. Jueyin governs tendon membrane fluids; drying causes Jueyin syndrome. Shaoyin governs lower jiao qi and fluids; exhaustion causes Shaoyin syndrome. This describes heat transformation. Cold transformation involves yang deficiency leading to downward leakage and upward reversal of cold water. Regardless of the organ injured, the corresponding meridian syndrome appears.

Tenth, cold and heat transformations depend on the individual’s constitutional yin-yang and deficiency-excess status. This statement is simple yet profound. After erroneous sweating, internal cold or heat may arise. After erroneous purging, internal cold or heat may also arise. Rigidly applying examples of excessive sweating destroying yang or excessive purging destroying yin is inappropriate. Readers should interpret contextually. Six meridians transmit via deficiency; cold and heat transform based on predisposition.

Eleventh, one must understand layers of interior-exterior relationships: morphological, meridianal, zang-fu, and qi-transformation levels. Morphological levels refer to skin, muscle, sinew, and bone. Pathogens in Taiyin regions are interior yet still exterior, suitable for sweating. Pathogens in Yangming meridians are exterior yet functionally interior, requiring clearing and harmonizing. Shaoyang is half-exterior, half-interior. Anatomically, it connects external meridians to the Triple Burner. Functionally, exterior cold persists while interior heat flourishes, showing signs of qi transformation and dryness.

Twelfth, hand and foot meridians are not fundamentally distinct. Foot meridians cover larger areas; when pathogens are superficial, outside meridians, their qi spreads broadly, presenting as foot meridian syndromes. When pathogens enter meridians, hand meridian syndromes often appear. Foot meridian syndromes usually relate to the body shell; hand meridian syndromes relate to zang-fu. Foot meridian syndromes may remain in meridians; hand meridian syndromes rarely do. Meridians relate to physical form; zang-fu relate to spirit and qi transformation.

Thirteenth, Three Yin and Three Yang are elegant names for meridian interior-exterior relationships, unrelated to zang-fu qi-blood yin-yang. Claiming entry into Three Yang injures yang and entry into Three Yin injures yin is incorrect. *Neijing* states Heart is Taiyang, Liver is Shaoyang, Lung is Shaoyin, Kidney is Taiyin, Spleen and Fu organs are Zhiyin, based on qi-blood clarity and turbidity. Modern practitioners ignore this. Each meridian, zang, and fu contains yin and yang. Studying *Neijing* clarifies this.

Fourteenth, readers must acknowledge uncertainties. *Treatise on Cold Damage* descriptions vary from concise to complex, with mismatches between formulas and syndromes, and disjointed texts. Applying oneself empathetically reveals difficulties in strict adherence. Could these be misplaced or missing bamboo slips? Do not waste effort; await future experience. For example, Shaoyang-Yangming combined disease with spontaneous diarrhea uses Huangqin Tang. Taiyang mismanaged with persistent diarrhea is heat-collateral diarrhea, using Chengqi Tang. This implies latent heat and turbid qi in Triple Burner and intestines, resembling warm diseases from latent pathogens, differing from typical typhoid diarrhea. For Taiyang mismanaged chest fullness, one should open and descend to release trapped yang, yet Gan Sui and Ba Dou are used for heavy purgation, compounding errors. For Shaoyang-Yangming combined disease with diarrhea, Gegen Tang is used; without diarrhea but with vomiting, Gegen Tang plus Ban Xia is used. Why use the original formula if no diarrhea? The formula treats combined disease, not diarrhea. Why mention diarrhea? Predecessors noted diarrhea in combined diseases but didn’t explain why, representing incomplete scholarship.

In summary, reading *Treatise on Cold Damage* requires immersing oneself in the original text. Commentaries number in dozens; I have seen over twenty, all prone to forced interpretations. They seem novel but fail clinical application. My view divides the text into four layers: 1. Treatment of primary syndromes in early typhoid; 2. Treatment of accompanying syndromes in early typhoid; 3. Treatment of cold transformation and mismanaged cold syndromes in late typhoid; 4. Treatment of heat transformation and mismanaged heat syndromes in late typhoid. Huoluan, wind-dampness, food relapse, and labor relapse are treated as miscellaneous diseases. Cross-reference Tao Jian’an’s works and warm disease commentaries for verification. This provides structure for study and pathways for clinical practice. While meridian locations and morphological depths must be studied, they should not be rigidly dogmatized. Emphasis must remain on qi transformation. The text varied before the Tang dynasty; chapter arrangements lack deep intent. Readers should contemplate the text independently without forcing connections, achieving mastery through accumulation.