(附∶脉微弱汗出恶风及筋惕肉 治法)
有太阳中风之脉,兼见太阳伤寒之脉者,大青龙汤所主之证是也。
《伤寒论》原文∶太阳中风,脉浮紧,发热,恶寒,身疼痛,不汗出而烦躁,大青龙汤主之。若
脉微弱,汗出恶风者,不可服,服则厥逆,筋惕肉 ,此为逆也。
【大青龙汤方】麻黄六两去节,桂枝二两去皮,甘草二两炙,杏仁五十个去皮尖,生姜三两切,
大枣十二枚擘。石膏如鸡子大碎(如鸡子大当有今之三两)。
上七味,以水九升先煮麻黄减二升,去上沫,纳诸药煮取三升,去滓温服一升,取微似汗,汗出多者温
粉扑之。一服汗者停后服。汗多亡阳遂虚,恶风烦躁,不得眠也。
此大青龙汤所主之证,原系胸中先有蕴热,又为风寒锢其外表,致其胸中之蕴热有蓄极外越之势。而
其锢闭之风寒,而犹恐芍药苦降酸敛之性,似于发汗不宜,而代以石膏,且多用之以浓
其力,其辛散凉润之性,既能助麻、桂达表,又善化胸中蕴蓄之热为汗,随麻、桂透表而出也,为有云腾致雨
之象,是以名为大青龙也。至于脉微弱汗出恶风者,原系胸中大气虚损,不能固摄卫气,即使有热亦是虚阳
外浮,若误投以大青龙汤,人必至虚者益虚,其人之元阳因气分虚极而欲脱,遂致肝风萌动而筋惕肉 也。夫
大青龙汤既不可用,遇此证者自当另有治法,拟用生黄 、生杭芍各五钱,麻黄钱半,煎汤一次服下,此
用麻黄以逐其外感,黄 以补其气虚,芍药以清其虚热也。为方中有黄 以补助气分,故麻黄仍可少用也。若其
人已误服大青龙汤,而大汗亡阳,筋惕肉 者,宜去方中麻黄加净萸肉一两。
《伤寒论》原文∶伤寒脉浮缓,身不疼,但重,乍有轻时,无少阴证者,大青龙汤发之。
细思此节之文,知所言之证原系温病,而节首冠以伤寒二字者,因中风、温病在本书之定例,均可名为
伤寒也。凡外感之脉多浮,以其多兼中风也。前节言伤寒脉浮紧,是所中者为凛冽之寒风,是中风兼伤寒也。
后节言伤寒脉浮缓,知所中者非凛冽之寒风,当为柔和之温风,既中柔和之温风,则即成风温矣。是以病
为伤寒必胸中烦躁而后可用石膏,至温病其胸中不烦躁,亦恒可用石膏,且其身不疼但重,伤寒第六节温病
提纲中,原明言身重此明征也。况其证乍有轻时,若在伤寒必不复重用石膏,惟温病虽有轻时,亦可重用石
膏。又伤寒初得有少阴证,若温病则始终无少阴证(少阴证有寒有热,此言无少阴证,指少阴之寒证而言,少
阴寒证断不可用大青龙汤,至少阴热证,原为伏气化热窜入少阴,虽在初得亦可治以大青龙汤,此又不可不知),
此尤不为伤寒而为温病之明征也。由此观之,是此节原为治温病者说法,欲其急清燥热以存真阴为先务也。至愚
用此方治温病时,恒以薄荷代方中桂枝,尤为稳妥。
凡发汗所用之药,其或凉或热,贵与病适宜。其初得病寒者
宜用热药发其汗,初得病热者宜用凉药发其汗。如大青龙汤证,
若投以麻黄汤则以热济热,恒不能出汗,即或出汗其病不惟不解,转益增烦躁,惟于麻、桂汤中去芍药,
重加石膏多于麻、桂数倍,其凉润轻散之性,与胸中之烦躁化合自能作汗,矧有麻黄之
善透表者以助之,故服后复杯之顷,即可周身得汗也。
曾治一人冬日得伤寒证,胸中异常烦躁,医者不识为大青龙汤证,竟投以麻黄汤,服后分毫无汗,胸中
烦躁益甚,自觉屋隘莫能容,诊其脉洪滑而浮,治以大青龙汤,为加天花粉八钱,服后五分钟,周身汗出
如洗,病若失。
或问∶服桂枝汤者,宜微似有汗,不可令如水流漓,病必不除,服麻黄汤者,复取微似汗,知亦不可令汗
如水流漓也。今于大青龙汤中加花粉,服汤后竟汗出如洗而病若失者何也?答曰∶善哉问也,此中原有妙理,
非此问莫能发之。凡伤寒、温病,皆忌伤其阴分,桂枝汤证与麻黄汤证,禁过发汗者恐伤其阴分也。
至大青龙汤证,其胸中蕴有燥热,得重量之石膏则化合而为汗,其燥热愈深者,化合之汗愈多,非尽量透发
于外,其燥热即不能彻底清肃,是以此等汗不出则已,出则如时雨沛然莫可遏抑。盖麻黄、桂枝等汤,皆
用药以祛病,得微汗则药力即能胜病,是以无事过汗以伤阴分。至大青龙汤乃合麻、桂为一方,又去芍药之酸
收,益以石膏之辛凉,其与胸中所蕴之燥热化合,犹如冶红之铁沃之以水,其热气自然蓬勃四达,此乃调燮
其阴阳,听其自汗,此中精微之理,与服桂枝、麻黄两汤不可过汗者,迥不侔也。
或问∶大青龙汤证,当病之初得何以胸中即蕴此大热?答曰∶此伤寒中伏气化热证也(温病中有伏气化
热,伤寒中亦有伏气化热)。因从前所受外寒甚轻,不能遽病,惟伏藏于三焦脂膜之中,阻塞升降之气化,久
而化热,后又因薄受外感之激动,其热陡发,窜入胸中空旷之府,
不汗出而烦躁,夫胸中原为太阳之府,为其犹在太阳,是以其热虽甚而仍可汗解也。
(Attachment: Treatment methods for weak pulse, sweating, aversion to wind, and muscle twitching/trembling)
When the pulse of Taiyang Wind Strike (Taiyang Zhong Feng) is present, accompanied by the pulse characteristics of Taiyang Cold Damage (Taiyang Shang Han), this constitutes the syndrome primarily treated by Da Qing Long Tang (Great Blue Dragon Decoction).
The original text of *Shanghan Lun* states: In Taiyang Wind Strike, if the pulse is floating and tight, with fever, aversion to cold, body pain, absence of sweating, and restlessness, Da Qing Long Tang should be administered. However, if the pulse is weak and faint, with sweating and aversion to wind, it must not be taken; taking it will result in cold extremities (Jue Ni) and muscle twitching/trembling (Jin Ti Rou Gu), which constitutes a therapeutic error (Ni).
[Formula for Da Qing Long Tang] Mahuang (Ephedrae Herba) 6 liang, stripped of nodes; Guizhi (Cinnamomi Ramulus) 2 liang, stripped of bark; Gancao (Glycyrrhizae Radix et Rhizoma) 2 liang, honey-fried; Xingren (Armeniacae Semen Amarum) 50 pieces, stripped of skin and tips; Shengjiang (Zingiberis Rhizoma Recens) 3 liang, sliced; Dazao (Ziziphi Jujubae Fructus) 12 pieces, torn open. Shi Gao (Gypsum Fibrosum) the size of a chicken egg, crushed (a piece of gypsum the size of a chicken egg corresponds approximately to 3 liang in modern measurement).
Take the above seven ingredients, add nine sheng of water, first decoct Mahuang until two sheng are reduced, skim off the foam on the surface, then add the remaining herbs. Decoct until three sheng remain, strain the dregs, and take one sheng warm. Aim for a slight sweat. If sweating is excessive, apply Wen Fen (warm powder) to the body to stop sweating. If sweating occurs after the first dose, discontinue subsequent doses. Excessive sweating leading to Yang collapse and deficiency may cause aversion to wind, restlessness, and insomnia.
This syndrome indicated by Da Qing Long Tang originally involves latent heat accumulating in the chest, bound by wind-cold on the exterior, causing the internal heat to accumulate to an extreme degree and seek to escape outward. Regarding the binding wind-cold, there was concern that the bitter-descending and sour-astringent nature of Shaoyao (Paeoniae Radix Alba/Rubra) might hinder sweating. Therefore, Shi Gao (Gypsum Fibrosum) is used instead, in larger quantities to enhance efficacy. The pungent-dispersing and cool-moistening nature of Shi Gao can both assist Mahuang and Guizhi in reaching the exterior and effectively transform the accumulated heat in the chest into sweat, which exits with the penetrating action of Mahuang and Guizhi. This resembles clouds rising to produce rain, hence the name "Great Blue Dragon." As for cases with weak pulse, sweating, and aversion to wind, these originally stem from deficiency and damage of the Great Qi (Da Qi) in the chest, failing to secure the Wei Qi (Defensive Qi). Even if heat is present, it is floating Deficient Yang. Misadministration of Da Qing Long Tang will exacerbate the deficiency, causing Yuan Yang (Primal Yang) to collapse due to extreme Qi deficiency, thereby stirring Liver Wind and resulting in muscle twitching/trembling. Since Da Qing Long Tang is contraindicated, a different treatment method is required for such cases. I propose using Sheng Huangqi (Astragali Radix) and Sheng Baishao (Paeoniae Radix Alba) each at 5 qian, and Mahuang (Ephedrae Herba) at 1.5 qian, decocted and taken once. Here, Mahuang expels external pathogens, Huangqi tonifies Qi deficiency, and Baishao clears deficient heat. Because Huangqi supplements the Qi aspect, Mahuang can still be used in small amounts. If a patient has already mistakenly taken Da Qing Long Tang, resulting in profuse sweating, Yang collapse, and muscle twitching/trembling, remove Mahuang from the formula and add Jing Yurou (Corni Fructus) at 1 liang.
The original text of *Shanghan Lun* states: In Shanghan (Cold Damage), if the pulse is floating and slow, the body does not ache but feels heavy, occasionally feeling lighter, and there are no Shaoyin syndrome signs, Da Qing Long Tang can be used to induce sweating.
Upon careful reflection of this passage, it is evident that the described syndrome is originally Wenyi (Warm Disease). The prefix "Shanghan" is used because, according to the conventions of this book, both Zhongfeng (Wind Strike) and Wenyi can be termed Shanghan. Most external contraction pulses are floating because they often involve Wind Strike. The previous section mentioned Shanghan with a floating-tight pulse, indicating the pathogen was biting cold wind, constituting Wind Strike combined with Cold Damage. The latter section mentions Shanghan with a floating-slow pulse, indicating the pathogen was not biting cold wind but gentle warm wind. Contracting gentle warm wind leads to Fengwen (Wind-Warmth). Thus, for a disease classified as Shanghan, Shi Gao (Gypsum Fibrosum) is used only if there is chest restlessness. For Wenyi, even without chest restlessness, Shi Gao can often be used. Furthermore, the symptom of body heaviness without pain aligns with the description in the sixth section's outline of Wenyi in *Shanghan Lun*, providing clear evidence. Moreover, since the symptoms occasionally lighten, if it were Shanghan, Shi Gao would not be heavily used; however, in Wenyi, even with occasional relief, heavy use of Shi Gao is permissible. Additionally, if early-stage Shanghan presents with Shaoyin signs, Wenyi never presents with Shaoyin signs throughout (Shaoyin syndromes include both cold and heat; here, "no Shaoyin signs" refers specifically to Shaoyin Cold Syndrome. Shaoyin Cold Syndrome absolutely contraindicates Da Qing Long Tang. However, Shaoyin Heat Syndrome, arising from latent heat transforming and invading Shaoyin, can be treated with Da Qing Long Tang even in early stages; this distinction must be known). This further confirms it is Wenyi rather than Shanghan. From this perspective, this section provides guidance for treating Wenyi, emphasizing the urgent need to clear dry-heat to preserve True Yin. When I use this formula to treat Wenyi, I often substitute Bohe (Menthae Haplocalycis Herba) for Guizhi (Cinnamomi Ramulus), which is particularly safe.
For all drugs used to induce sweating, whether cooling or heating, suitability to the disease is paramount. For initial cold diseases, hot drugs should be used to induce sweating; for initial heat diseases, cooling drugs should be used. In the case of Da Qing Long Tang syndrome, if Mahuang Tang (Ephedra Decoction) were administered, it would be adding heat to heat, often failing to induce sweat. Even if sweat occurs, the disease will not resolve but restlessness will increase. Only by removing Shaoyao from Mahuang Tang/Guizhi Tang and heavily increasing Shi Gao (several times the amount of Mahuang and Guizhi) can its cooling, moistening, and light-dispersing nature combine with chest restlessness to naturally produce sweat. Assisted by Mahuang's ability to penetrate the exterior, sweat can be achieved throughout the body shortly after ingestion.
I once treated a patient who contracted Shanghan in winter, presenting with extreme chest restlessness. The physician failed to recognize this as a Da Qing Long Tang syndrome and administered Mahuang Tang. After ingestion, no sweat occurred, and chest restlessness intensified; the patient felt the room was too small to contain them. The pulse was洪滑 (surging, slippery, and floating). I treated with Da Qing Long Tang, adding Huafen (Trichosanthis Radix) at 8 qian. Five minutes after ingestion, the patient sweated profusely as if washed, and the illness seemed to vanish.
Someone asked: For those taking Guizhi Tang, slight perspiration is appropriate; sweating like flowing water must be avoided, otherwise the disease will not be cured. For those taking Mahuang Tang, slight perspiration is also sought, implying sweating like flowing water is also prohibited. Now, with Huafen added to Da Qing Long Tang, why does the patient sweat profusely yet recover completely? I reply: Excellent question. There is profound logic herein, revealed only by this inquiry. Both Shanghan and Wenyi must avoid damaging the Yin aspect. Guizhi Tang and Mahuang Tang prohibit excessive sweating to prevent Yin damage. However, in Da Qing Long Tang syndrome, dry-heat accumulates in the chest. Combined with large amounts of Shi Gao, this transforms into sweat. The deeper the dry-heat, the more sweat is produced. Unless thoroughly vented outward, the dry-heat cannot be completely cleared. Therefore, such sweat, once it starts, pours down like heavy rain, unstoppable. Generally, formulas like Mahuang Tang and Guizhi Tang use drugs to dispel disease; once slight sweat occurs, the drug's power suffices to overcome the disease, so excessive sweating to damage Yin is unnecessary. Da Qing Long Tang combines Mahuang and Guizhi, removes the astringent nature of Shaoyao, and adds the pungent-cool nature of Shi Gao. Its combination with the dry-heat in the chest is like pouring water on red-hot iron; the heat naturally expands vigorously. This harmonizes and regulates Yin and Yang, allowing spontaneous sweating. The subtle principle here differs vastly from the prohibition against excessive sweating in Guizhi and Mahuang Tangs.
Someone asked: Why does Da Qing Long Tang syndrome present with such intense heat in the chest right from the onset of the disease? I reply: This is a syndrome of latent heat transforming within Shanghan (Wenyi also features latent heat transformation; Shanghan does as well). Previously contracted external cold was mild, insufficient to cause immediate illness, but it lurked within the Sanjiao (Triple Burner) fatty membranes, obstructing the ascending and descending Qi dynamics. Over time, it transformed into heat. Later, triggered by a mild new external contraction, the heat suddenly erupted,窜入 (invading) the empty cavity of the chest, causing absence of sweating and restlessness. The chest is originally the domain of the Taiyang channel. Since the pathogen remains in Taiyang, despite the intensity of the heat, it can still be resolved through sweating.