Library

Tonification refers to replenishing deficiency. The Classics state: "If one cannot treat deficiency, how can one attend to other conditions?" It also states: "Where pathogenic factors gather, Qi must be deficient." Furthermore: "Loss of essence and Qi results in deficiency." And: "Deficiency is treated with tonification." The significance of tonification is indeed profound! However, there are errors where tonification should have been applied but was not, harming the patient; where tonification was inappropriately applied, harming the patient; and where, although tonification was indicated, the practitioner failed to distinguish between Qi and Blood, did not differentiate Cold and Heat, ignored the principles of opening and closing, did not know the urgency or slowness of treatment, failed to distinguish among the Five Zang organs, did not clarify the root cause, and did not deeply seek proper regimens for regulation, thereby harming the patient. These matters require careful study.

What constitutes the error of "failing to tonify when indicated"? Deficiency is the gradual accumulation of damage; damage is the long-term aggregation of deficiency. Initially, it may go unnoticed, but over time, disease forms. If Yang deficiency is not tonified, Qi will gradually diminish. If Yin deficiency is not tonified, Blood will gradually be consumed. With both diminution and consumption, the innate True Qi and Ying-Wei (Nutritive and Defensive) Qi will gradually cease, and depletion will become established. Even if one wishes to tonify at this point, it will be too late. There are also cases of severe deficiency where internal substance is insufficient, yet externally there appears to be excess. The pulse is floating, large, and choppy; the face is red as if on fire; the body feels swollen and dizzy; there is irritability and restlessness. This indicates a mechanism for collapse due to excessive sweating. In more severe cases, spirit is scattered, and insomnia persists throughout the night; the danger is even more rapid. The treatment should employ formulas such as Yang Rong Tang (Nourish the Blood Decoction) or Gui Pi Tang (Restore the Spleen Decoction), adding astringent herbs to gather and secure the Yuan Shen (Original Spirit). This allows the scattered Qi to retreat and store itself within, offering a chance for rescue. In cases of Yin deficiency with hyperactive Fire, where Qi rebels upward causing insomnia, the treatment should nourish Kidney Water to control the Fire. One must strictly avoid bitter-cold purgative herbs that drain Fire, as they will injure True Qi. Misusing clearing herbs would distance the patient from recovery. As the ancients said, "Extreme deficiency presents with symptoms of excess; wrongly using purgation leads to unjust suffering." This illustrates the error of failing to tonify when indicated.

However, there are also errors of "tonifying when inappropriate." Why? Cases presenting with a full pulse and full syndrome, which cannot tolerate tonification, need no further discussion. Even if a person's constitution is inherently weak, if external pathogenic factors have just invaded and the disease momentum is strong, sudden tonification amounts to "locking the door and keeping the thief inside." Conversely, there are cases of extreme excess where accumulated heat resides internally, yet the pulse is fine and choppy, consciousness is clouded, and the body is fatigued. The patient may even shiver with aversion to cold, desiring extra clothing, closely mimicking a deficiency-cold pattern. However, such individuals invariably present with cracked lips, dry mouth, constipation, and dark urine—symptoms worlds apart from true deficiency. If these are not distinguished precisely, and tonifying agents are mistakenly administered, it is a grave error. As the ancients stated, "Extreme excess presents with symptoms of weakness; wrongly tonifying exacerbates the disease." This illustrates the error of tonifying when inappropriate.

There are also instances where tonification fails to distinguish between Qi and Blood, or Cold and Heat. The Classics state: "Qi provides warmth; Blood provides moisture." For tonifying Qi, Si Jun Zi Tang (Four Gentlemen Decoction) is used; all Qi-tonifying herbs derive from this principle. For tonifying Blood, Si Wu Tang (Four Substance Decoction) is used; all Blood-tonifying herbs derive from this principle. However, Shao Huo (Mild Fire, referring to physiological Fire) is the source of generating Qi. The Dantian is the sea of Qi emission. Tonifying Qi without addressing Fire is incorrect. One must understand that while Shao Huo generates Qi, Zhuang Huo (Excessive Fire, referring to pathological Fire) consumes Qi. For example, in heatstroke, limbs lack strength; in damp-heat leading to flaccidity syndromes where movement is impossible, Fire has injured Qi. People know that tonifying Fire can benefit Qi, but do not realize that clearing Fire can also benefit Qi. While the outcome of tonification is similar, the nature of Cold and Heat differs. For Blood-Heat syndromes, one should tonify and move Blood to clear Heat. For Blood-Cold syndromes, one should warm the channels and nourish Blood to harmonize. Xue Li-zhai’s therapeutic principles state: For hematemesis due to Blood-Heat, termed "Yang invading Yin," caused by Heat forcing Blood to move recklessly, treat with Si Sheng Wan (Four Generations Pill) or Liu Wei Di Huang Wan (Six-Ingredient Rehmannia Pill). For hematemesis due to Blood-Cold, termed "Yin invading Yang," akin to water freezing into ice on a cold day, treat with Li Zhong Tang (Regulate the Middle Decoction) plus Dang Gui (Angelica Sinensis). Physicians must recognize this to avoid errors. In cases of massive blood loss, regardless of Cold or Heat, tonification is necessary. This follows the principle: "In blood loss, tonify Qi," which reflects the supreme truth of "Yang generation leads to Yin growth." Formidable Blood cannot be generated quickly, whereas formless Qi must be urgently secured. Generating the tangible from the intangible follows the natural creation of Heaven and Earth. This distinguishes Qi from Blood, and Cold from Heat.

There are also cases where tonification ignores the principles of opening/closing and urgency/slowness. The principle of Heaven and Earth dictates that closure implies opening; the mechanism of herbal medicine dictates that tonification implies purging. For instance, Bu Zhong Yi Qi Tang uses Ren Shen (Ginseng) but must include Chen Pi (Tangerine Peel) to open and circulate; Liu Wei Di Huang Wan uses Shu Di Huang (Prepared Rehmannia) but includes Ze Xie (Alisma) to guide out turbidity. Ancients used herbs to tonify Zheng Qi (Upright Qi) while simultaneously draining Xie Qi (Pathogenic Qi); once pathogens are removed, tonification becomes effective. Moreover, in deficiency complicated by pathogens, one must open a pathway, pacify the people (healthy Qi), and attack the thieves (pathogens), employing strategies of release and capture, retention and discharge. This ensures the retreat of pathogens and peace of the people, strengthening the foundation of the state. One must weigh the strength of pathogens versus healthy Qi and adjust dosages accordingly. Thus, ancient formulas include combinations of tonification and dispersion, such as Shen Su Yin (Ginseng and Perilla Drink) and Yi Qi Tang (Benefit Qi Decoction); combinations of resolution and tonification, such as Zhi Zhu Wan (Immature Bitter Orange and Atractylodes Pill) and Li Zhong Wan; combinations of attack and tonification, such as Xie Xin Tang (Drain the Epigastrium Decoction) and Xiao Shi Wan; combinations of warming and tonification, such as Zhi Zhong Tang and Shen Fu Tang (Ginseng and Aconite Decoction); and combinations of clearing and tonification, such as Shen Lian Yin and Ren Shen Bai Hu Tang (Ginseng and White Tiger Decoction). Some cases require vigorous tonification, others slow tonification, and others mild tonification. For extremely weak patients in critical condition, large doses of decoctions are needed to reverse the decline. I have used concentrated pastes of Ren Shen and Fu Zi (Aconite) taken in large quantities daily to rescue cases of Yang collapse. I have also used pastes of Ren Shen and Mai Dong (Ophiopogon) to rescue cases of impending fluid exhaustion. Sometimes, due to inability to afford Ren Shen, Bai Zhu (Atractylodes Macrocephala) and Fu Ling (Poria) are substituted. Treatment adapted to circumstances often yields success. When pathogens remain and Yuan Qi is deficient but cannot tolerate heavy tonification, one should tonify gently and steadily, observing indications and proceeding step-by-step. As pulse and symptoms stabilize, reduce dosage gradually, and use dietary therapy with grains, meats, fruits, and vegetables to achieve full health. For those with inherent weakness but no extreme Cold or Heat, who wish to use pills and powders to preserve Yuan Yuan, use mild herbs to regulate Qi and Blood. Avoid eccentric formulas that compete aggressively, as prolonged use may cause harm. This explains the meaning of opening/closing and urgency/slowness.

There are also cases where tonification fails to distinguish among the Five Zang organs. Each Zang organ has a direct method of tonification and a method based on the generating cycle. The Nan Jing states: "For lung injury, benefit its Qi; for heart injury, harmonize Ying and Wei; for spleen injury, regulate diet and adapt to temperature; for liver injury, soothe its center; for kidney injury, benefit its Essence." This is direct tonification. Alternatively, tonify the Spleen for Lung deficiency (Earth generates Metal); tonify the Ming Men (Gate of Life) for Spleen deficiency (Fire generates Earth); tonify the Liver for Heart deficiency (Wood generates Fire); tonify the Kidneys for Liver deficiency (Water generates Wood); tonify the Lungs for Kidney deficiency (Metal generates Water). This is tonification via the generating cycle. I further propose the concept of "Roots." At conception, before form is complete, the two Kidneys develop first; the Kidneys are the root of Pre-Heaven (Innate) constitution. Upon birth, seeking milk and food comes first; the Spleen is the root of Post-Heaven (Acquired) constitution. Within the Pre-Heaven, there is Water and Fire. Water is called True Yin, and Fire is called True Yang. Named "True," they are neither Qi nor Blood, but the mothers of Qi and Blood. Life and bodily formation rely entirely on them. Zhou Dunyi stated: "The true essence of the Wuji, the essence of the Two Modes and Five Phases, combine wondrously and condense. Still and unmoving, yet responsive and communicating, following the spirit in its coming and going." The ancients understood this well. They used Liu Wei Di Huang Wan to nourish Water, Ba Wei Di Huang Wan (Eight-Ingredient Rehmannia Pill) to tonify Fire, and Shi Bu Wan (Ten-Tonifying Pill) or Ban Long Wan, balancing Water and Fire. Their methods were sound. However, using artificial means to supplement the True requires that the True essence not be completely lost for efficacy to occur. If the ancestral Qi of Pre-Heaven is utterly depleted, even Lingzhi (Reishi Mushroom) cannot prolong life, let alone common herbs. The Post-Heaven root, especially the Spleen, must be cultivated and cannot be neglected. The Classics state: "Abundance of grain signifies prosperity; absence of grain signifies peril." Also: "When gruel enters the Stomach, the deficient revive." Ancient physicians always spoke of "Stomach Qi" when taking pulses. Formulas are named "Bu Zhong" (Tonify the Middle) or "Gui Pi" (Return to the Spleen) and "Jian Pi" (Strengthen the Spleen) for good reason. Food entering the Stomach distributes to the Five Zang organs and irrigates the body, like military provisions or civilian hearth fires. If supply ceases, soldiers and civilians scatter. While many diseases arise from hunger, many also arise from dietary injury. Excessive consumption of rich, sweet foods generates Phlegm; excessive alcohol creates Fluid retention; fruits, dairy, and butter introduce Dampness internally, leading to edema, distension, and diarrhea. Prolonged preference for any of the Five Flavors increases specific Qi disproportionately, leading to premature death. How can one not be cautious? Thus, it is known that both the Spleen and Kidneys are roots and cannot be neglected. Some say tonifying the Spleen is inferior to tonifying the Kidneys because Ming Men Fire generates Spleen Earth; others say tonifying the Kidneys is inferior to tonifying the Spleen because essence from food naturally descends to the Kidneys. One must know: if the Spleen is weak but Kidneys are intact, prioritize tonifying the Spleen; if Kidneys are weak but Spleen is intact, prioritize tonifying the Kidneys; if both are weak, tonify both. After medicinal tonification, proper regimen and care are essential. As the proverb says: "Medicinal tonification is inferior to dietary tonification." I say: "Dietary tonification is inferior to Essence tonification; Essence tonification is inferior to Spirit tonification." Regulate diet, cherish Spirit, and apply medication appropriately; few illnesses will fail to heal.