(素问五常政大论)
帝曰∶其久病者,有气从不康,病去而瘠奈何?(谓气已顺而身犹不康,病已去而形则瘠瘦也。瘠音寂。)岐伯曰∶
昭乎哉圣人之问也。化不可代,时不可违。(化,造化也。凡造化之道,衰王各有不同,如木从春化,火从夏化,金从秋
化,水从冬化,土从四季之化,以及五运六气各有所主,皆不可以相代也,故曰化不可代。人之脏气,亦必随时以为衰
王,欲复脏气之亏,不因时气不可也,故曰时不可违。不违时者,如金水根于春夏,木火基于秋冬,脏气皆有化原,设
不预为之地,则临时不易于复元,或邪气乘虚再至,虽有神手,无如之何矣。愚按∶此节诸注皆谓天地有自然之化,人
力不足以代之,故曰化不可代。然则当听之矣,而下文曰养之和之者,又将何所为乎?谓非以人力而赞天工者乎?其说
不然也。)夫经络以通,血气以从,复其不足,与众齐同,(疾病既去而不求其复,则元气由衰而瘠矣。养之和之,静以
待时,谨守其气,无使倾移,其形乃彰,生气以长,命曰圣王。(养者,养以气味。和者,和以性情。静以待时者,预有
修为而待时以复也。如阳虚者喜春夏,阴虚者喜秋冬,病在肝者愈于夏,病在心者愈于长夏,病在脾者愈于秋,病在肺
者愈于冬,病在肾者愈于春,皆其义也。谨守其气,无使倾移,则固有弗失,日新可期,是即撤消之道,而生气可渐长
矣。)故大要曰∶无代化,无违时,必养必和,待其来复。此之谓也。帝曰∶善。(大要,上古书名。此引古语以明化不
可代,时不可失,不可不养,不可不和,以待其来复,未有不复者矣。来复之义,即易之复卦,一阳生于五阴之下,阳
气渐回则生意渐长,同此理也。)
(Su Wen, Chapter on the Great Regularity of Natural Changes)
The Yellow Emperor asked: For those suffering from chronic diseases, why is it that although their Qi has become smooth and they have not yet recovered, and although the pathogenic factors have departed, their bodies remain emaciated? (This means that although the Qi has harmonized, the body remains unwell; although the disease has passed, the form becomes thin and emaciated. "Ji" is pronounced as "ji".)
Qibo replied:
How profound is your question, O Sage! The transformations of nature cannot be substituted by human effort, and the timing of the seasons must not be violated. (Transformation refers to the creative processes of nature. The principles of creation vary in their waxing and waning; for instance, Wood transforms in Spring, Fire in Summer, Metal in Autumn, Water in Winter, and Earth in the transition periods of the four seasons. Furthermore, the Five Movements and Six Qi each have their respective dominions, none of which can replace another; hence it is said that natural transformation cannot be substituted. The Qi of the Zang organs also necessarily waxes and wanes according to the seasons. To restore the deficiency of the Zang Qi without adhering to the seasonal Qi is impossible; hence it is said that the timing of the seasons must not be violated. Not violating the timing implies, for example, that Metal and Water are rooted in Spring and Summer, while Wood and Fire are based in Autumn and Winter. The transformation of Zang Qi has its origins; if preparation is not made in advance, recovery at the critical moment will be difficult, or pathogenic factors may take advantage of the deficiency to return. Even with divine skill, nothing could be done. My commentary: All previous annotations on this section attribute the statement "transformation cannot be substituted" to the natural changes of Heaven and Earth, which human power cannot replace. If so, should we simply leave things to chance? Yet the following text speaks of "nourishing and harmonizing." What purpose does this serve? Is it not to assist the work of Heaven through human effort? This interpretation is incorrect.) One must ensure the meridians are unobstructed and the Blood and Qi flow smoothly, restoring deficiencies until one's condition is equal to that of a healthy person. (If, after the disease has departed, one does not seek recovery, the Original Qi will decline and lead to emaciation. Through nourishment and harmony, waiting quietly for the right time, carefully guarding the Qi to prevent its depletion or deviation, the physical form will be restored, and the vital energy will grow. This is called the way of the Sage King. "Nourishing" refers to nourishing with flavors and aromas. "Harmonizing" refers to harmonizing with emotions and temperament. "Waiting quietly for the time" implies cultivating oneself in advance and awaiting the opportune moment for recovery. For example, those with Yang deficiency favor Spring and Summer, while those with Yin deficiency favor Autumn and Winter. Liver diseases tend to heal in Summer, Heart diseases in Late Summer, Spleen diseases in Autumn, Lung diseases in Winter, and Kidney diseases in Spring; all these illustrate this principle. By carefully guarding the Qi and preventing its loss or deviation, the inherent vitality will not be lost, and daily renewal can be expected. This is the method of eliminating pathology, allowing vital energy to gradually increase.) Therefore, the general principle states: Do not substitute natural transformation, do not violate the timing of the seasons; you must nourish and harmonize, and wait for the spontaneous recovery. This is what is meant.
The Yellow Emperor said: Excellent. ("Da Yao" is an ancient book title. Here, an ancient saying is quoted to clarify that natural transformation cannot be substituted, seasonal timing must not be missed, and one must neither neglect nourishment nor harmony, in order to await spontaneous recovery. There is no case where recovery does not occur. The meaning of "returning/recovery" corresponds to the Hexagram Fu (Return) in the I Ching, where one Yang line arises beneath five Yin lines; as Yang Qi gradually returns, the vitality gradually increases, following the same logic.)